A rich, layered Southern novel about friendship, rivalry, faith, and the emotional collisions that shape young lives inside a Catholic girls’ school.
 
At Mount St. Gabriel’s, a prestigious all-girls school in the mountains of North Carolina, a new school year brings buried tensions to the surface. When headstrong ninth-grader Tildy Stratton clashes with charismatic new student Chloe Starnes—who carries her own tragic history—their rivalry sets off a chain of events that changes the community forever.
 
Set in the mid-20th century, the novel centers on Mount St. Gabriel’s, a Catholic girls’ academy run by dedicated but flawed nuns. As the school prepares to celebrate its centennial, former students and faculty revisit a pivotal year marked by a fierce rivalry, adolescent insecurity, and a tragedy that left lasting scars.
 
Through shifting timelines and multiple perspectives, Godwin examines the complexities of girlhood, religious devotion, longing, and the weight of unresolved guilt. Each character—students and nuns alike—is rendered with empathy and nuance, revealing how faith, secrets, and unspoken desires shape individuals and communities.
 
Unfinished Desires is Gail Godwin at her finest: deeply observant, emotionally intelligent, and steeped in Southern atmosphere.  This is a beautifully written, character-driven novel perfect for readers who love thoughtful, emotionally rich storytelling.
 
💖 Why You’ll Love It
Deeply emotional Southern storytelling with historical depth
Rich character development, especially among adolescent girls
Strong themes of faith, rivalry, guilt, and forgiveness
Beautiful prose from an award-winning literary author
Works well for book clubs with layered discussions
 
🌟 Perfect For
Fans of literary and Southern fiction
Readers who enjoy school-based drama and coming-of-age themes
Book clubs seeking complex, character-driven narratives
Fans of Sue Monk Kidd, Ann Patchett, or Elizabeth Strout
Those interested in faith, community, and emotional redemption
 
❤️ Fans Also Liked
The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd
The Cloister Walk by Kathleen Norris
The Girls of Slender Means by Muriel Spark